Whisky Goodness Logo
Whisky Goodness

Truly A Gem!

Caol IlaSMWS 53.458

Producer: SMWS

February 16, 2026
View Source
About This Whisky

Code

53.458

Distillery

Caol Ila

Name

Truly A Gem!

Producer

SMWS

Region

Islay

Age

9 years

ABV

56.8%

Bottler Type

Independent

Category

Scotch

Flavor Profile

Peated

Nose

The whisky presents a briny, aromatic profile reminiscent of grilled sardines with garlic, olive oil, fresh coriander, and paprika, accented by sea salt, pepper, and bright lemon zest.

Palate

On the palate, this cask delivers maritime and savory characteristics akin to Spanish braised octopus in sweet paprika sauce with olives and manzanilla sherry notes, while the addition of water introduces a rich, creamy texture balanced by sweet smoke and umami undertones of miso soup with smoked tofu.

Finish

The finish evokes the warmth of a bonfire on an Islay beach—a rounded, well-integrated conclusion that reflects seven years of maturation in ex-bourbon hogshead followed by first fill American oak oloroso cask influence, creating a complex and memorable conclusion.

Overall Notes

Imagine grilled sardines slathered with garlic, olive oil, chopped fresh coriander, paprika, sea salt and pepper, plus lemon juice and zest. On the palate we stayed with a maritime dish, this time, Spanish braised octopus in a sweet paprika sauce served with olives and a glass of manzanilla sherry. Water added a rich creamy note wonderfully balanced by the sweet smoke of a miso soup with crispy smoked tofu. To taste, we sat around a bonfire on the beach by the Sound of Islay with plenty of friends on a warm sunny evening – truly a gem! Following seven years in an ex-bourbon hogshead, we transferred this whisky into a first fill American oak oloroso hogshead.